Is opera having a moment? Lately we’re actually seeing lots of new operas.
I remember a time when new operas were a rarity, when it was a big deal to stage an opera from 24 years ago (the Canadian Opera Company’s 2011 staging Nixon in China that had premiered in 1987) or 36 years ago (Luminato’s 2012 staging of Einstein on the Beach, that had premiered in 1976).
But earlier this week I enjoyed the free Met Opera high definition broadcast of Lincoln in the Bardo, libretto by Royce Vavrek; I won’t write about it until I’ve read the novel, but I was powerfully moved by the work & the production. This week Royce’s Dog Days (2012) is getting its Canadian premiere production. I have reports by word of mouth that it’s very good, but I chose to skip it for the simple reason that I am already sleepless watching the news, without watching an opera about the end of the world, thanks very much.
And Thursday night I saw the World Premiere of Fall River: the legend of Lizzie Borden at the first of four performances at the Elgin Theatre, double cast by the University of Toronto’s Opera department.
The story of Lizzie Borden is in some respects an about face for the usual operatic plot. Last week I watched two popular works that do the usual thing, meaning Carmen (heroine is murdered) and Rigoletto (heroine is murdered). I have an ongoing conversation with Erika who asks over and over why opera must have these stories, so much misogyny and violence against women. Lizzie Borden could be the avenging diva of opera, for once killing rather than being killed. While that’s not why I think this adaptation of the story is good, its inversion of the usual operatic plot is a bit of subtext. In the realm where misogyny is the norm it almost feels like a happy ending.
I was alert and intrigued by the new work, never bored or yawning. With music by Cecilia Livingston, the beautiful staging by the Opera Dept of U of T held my attention throughout.
Its brilliant libretto is Michael Patrick Albano’s version of the story, delving beyond the facts to explore the psychology and family dynamics, plus the broader community who chose to acquit Lizzie.
I will start from the end.
In this very creepy nasty family, Uncle John is the one nice relative, appearing early on and then re-appearing near the end. He performs a function comparable to the psychiatrist at the end of Hitchcock’s Psycho. While you can skip the video I think it’s a useful bit of context for what we saw in the new Lizzie Borden opera.
You’ll remember that Hitchcock’s shrink gives us a variation on the usual 3 act structure seen in a George Bernard Shaw play, something usually consisting of 1-exposition 2-complication and then to conclude 3-discussion/debate. In Psycho the variant is to use the last section to explain/unpack the mystery, possibly complicating the story in the process. This offers an alternative way of unfolding a story, as well as giving us the moral conclusion to the conflict by explaining who really killed whom complete with an exploration of culpability.
Michael does something similar although he did it in two acts. The first act was truly exposition, taking us to the brink of the murder, the second act was largely flashbacks, beginning in the graveyard where Lizzie is arrested for the murder. We watch Lizzie’s sister Emma having nightmares, punctuated by moments of lurid courtroom commentary. And then later in the act the maid Bridget (Brooke Zarubin) gets a visit from Uncle John (Luca McCauley) who then did Hitchcock’s variant, teasing us with possibilities for solving the mystery. While Lizzie was acquitted in the trial, Michael tells us his verdict at the end (spoiler alert, stop reading if you don’t want to know), that I understand as his idea of who really killed Andrew & Abby Borden.

Uncle John is asking Bridget, a likely witness to the family’s behaviour, her opinion of what really happened. As he asks Bridget, he presents her with the four possible scenarios understood at the trial as pondered by the jury, something very similar to the way the psychiatrist reviews the murder in Psycho:
1-Emma could have done it and had motivation
2-Lizzie could have done it and had motivation
3-Bridget (the maid) could have done it and had motivation
4-an intruder broke in, possibly a debtor or robber, and killed them
We come to the end of the opera, to discover there’s a fifth possibility, that might represent Michael’s take on the story. that Lizzie and Emma colluded. The curtain comes down upon this scenario shown in a flashback, and please excuse me for the spoiler.
The dark family dynamics reminded me of Janacek’s Katya Kabanova, a place of entrapment with no escape. But where the Janacek has a sense of futility to it, I was surprised at the sense of karmic justice to this presentation of the story. Andrew Borden has lost his first wife, and then married again to Abby, and is in the process of changing his will. Both Abby and Andrew are strict to everyone in the house, including Bridget the housemaid & Andrew’s two daughters Emma & Lizzie.
I observed something Cecilia does that I’d call an evolved version of classical opera, a technique as an alternative to the old discourse alternating between recitative (verbal information with little lyricism) & aria or arioso (lyricism with less verbal information), by having singers sometimes repeating the same note, as a kind of recit construction but without breaking the flow of the scene & her arioso. Every now and then one of the personages would have a moment when they were called upon to do something more lyrical.
Lizzie (Sloane Ryan) had her moment in the first act, something resembling an aria when she expounded on the challenges of life and how she responded to it. She tells us of the beauty of her pigeons. Andrew Borden (Josh Gibson), played Lizzie & Emma’s father, a tyrannical figure who explodes at Lizzie when she speaks of changes to the will. In short order he gets even by killing her pigeons. The future seems clear, when the first act ends, Lizzie staring out into the audience as she holds the bloody axe he used on her birds. While we’re told he’s wealthy, one of the first things we see is his effort to avoid having to pay the doctor for a house-call, believing it’s a waste of money. No he’s not very nice: but did he deserve to be murdered? I don’t think so. And ditto for Abby.
Emma (Delaney Dam) seems to be a bit saner than her younger sister Lizzie, suggesting that Lizzie’s encounter with a married man in Paris (that we see acted out) was just something in Lizzie’s head, that it never happened. Sloane plays Lizzie very straight, deadpan & underplayed, making her dignified and mysterious without any melodrama. When she speaks of how she and Emma will have nice things, it’s troubling because we know that she has improved her wealth by the killing of her father & step-mother, underlined by the way her sister seems to recognize this or share some guilt over the improvement in their fortunes.
There’s a sort of motif we hear at the beginning that might be the sound of an axe, that recurs throughout, as a rhythm something like a beating heart. It sometimes migrates to the percussion, or to the piano, and doesn’t get in the way of the orchestral arioso writing. My terminology may be a bad approximation, but for much of the opera we’re in tonal territory, not terribly dissonant, although sometimes the pleasantly assonant music has scary momentary eruptions like unexpected coups de theatre, dramatic interventions as though the orchestra were trying to tell us not to trust the hymn tune, especially because the hymn tune speaks of putting axes to use. It’s creepy in the best way. While we’re scared at times, I didn’t worry about the end of the world, indeed a story like this is terrific escapism.
Sandra Horst conducted the members of the University of Toronto Symphony Orchestra and the sixteen choristers, who all sounded gorgeous. The singing was fully intelligible, helped by clear surtitles, but the cast did an excellent job enunciating Michael’s words. It helped too that Cecilia doesn’t push her singers into difficult virtuoso singing, the high notes coming in emotionally relevant places and underlining rather than obscuring meaning.
I was again mindful of how student theatre & opera can be exceptionally good, recalling the two chamber operas I saw at Glenn Gould Studio so recently. Students will follow the director, which is especially cool when the director is also the librettist. Granted, some of the performances were limited in scope, more or less standing & delivering without a lot of nuance or drama, but the principals were excellent. There’s plenty of scope for larger than life performances from professional singers (as I hope this opera will be done again by a professional company), although we were well served on this occasion by the disciplined and studious singers of the U of T Opera Department.
Fall River, the legend of Lizzie Borden continues at the Elgin Theatre, this cast repeating on Saturday Nov 21st, while the second cast performs Friday Nov 20th & Sunday Nov 22nd.




























People see the fame, the reviews, the beautiful photos, the applause, what they don’t see is the tears, the sweat, the panic attacks at 3am. I wake up daily thinking “is this what I really want to do?” But then when I take 2-3 weeks off I’m like “I’m bored! I want to sing again! I want to be on stage again!” It’s weird, it’s like… a drug and I’m definitely hooked! I meet wonderful people on this job. Some of them go on to become my chosen family. My community. But they’re scattered on all corners of the planet. That is also difficult. Since I’ve been doing this, I don’t feel a feeling of belonging to one place in particular. It is such a strange feeling. But I am still not willing to give it away just for now. I still have things to discover with music, opera, live performance, and myself.
















































